You can trust VideoGamer. Our team of gaming experts spend hours testing and reviewing the latest games, to ensure you're reading the most comprehensive guide possible. Rest assured, all imagery and advice is unique and original. Check out how we test and review games here
It’s happening! Madden 23 Ultimate Team (MUT) revealed its biggest announcement of the season yesterday, March 8, presenting fans with none other than its highly anticipated Team Of The Year (TOTY). The TOTY special live stream took place at 7PM ET, beholding one remarkable set of NFL stars that performed well-above expectations throughout the 2022 season.
Nearly three weeks ago, Madden 23 presented a total of 98 TOTY Nominees and allowed the fans to vote on who they felt should be on this special team honor. Following the close of the voting period, Madden 23 took the time and diligence to count the votes and determine which players made the TOTY.
READ MORE: All Week 7 Weekly Wildcards Players & Challenges – Madden 23
Fast forward to last night, and Madden 23 Ultimate Team has returned with its TOTY Winners, producing what are arguably the best cards to have in the game. Down below we’ve taken the time to detail the full TOTY Winners, the TOTY Honorable Mentions, the entire list of nominees, and our very own prediction of who we thought would qualify for the highly-coveted Madden 23 Team Of The Year.
With the in-game release now live today, March 9, we present you the Madden 23 TOTY, its nominees, and our expert prediction.
Madden 23 TOTY – The Winners
In this section, we cover the full list of TOTY Winners that made the final cut for this special Madden 23 team honor. On top of the TOTY players, Madden 23 also included a Most Valuable Virtual Player, which is the NFL star that received the most votes during the TOTY voting period.
Before diving into this exciting new release, there are some important details to keep in mind. One of the biggest details to make note of is that the TOTY Program comes with 40 Challenges, which allows fans to secure a 98 Overall Account Bound (BND) TOTY Fantasy Pack along with increments of 2,000 MUT Coin.
In addition, if you collected all 17 TOTY Tokens from completing the Team Of The Week (TOTW) Program Challenges during the 2022 NFL regular season, you can place them in a TOTY Collectible Exchange set to secure another 98 Overall TOTY Fantasy Pack containing your choice between 1 of 3 random TOTY Winners or Honorable Mentions.
That all said, the people have spoken. And based on the votes that were placed, MUT selected the following players to represent the Madden 23 TOTY:
Most Valuable Virtual Player (99 Overall)
- Fred Warner (MLB) – 49ers
Offense (98 Overall)
- Jalen Hurts (QB) – Eagles
- Christian McCaffrey (HB) – 49ers
- Justin Jefferson (WR) – Vikings
- Tyreek Hill (WR) – Dolphins
- A.J. Brown (WR) – Eagles
- Travis Kelce (TE) – Chiefs
- Trent Williams (LT) – 49ers
- Quenton Nelson (LG) – Colts
- Jason Kelce (C) – Eagles
- Zack Martin (RG) – Cowboys
- Lane Johnson (RT) – Eagles
Defense (98 Overall
- Chris Jones (DT) – Chiefs
- Nick Bosa (RE) – 49ers
- Maxx Crosby (LE) – Raiders
- Bobby Wagner (MLB) – Rams
- Micah Parsons (ROLB) – Cowboys
- Haason Reddick (LOLB) – Eagles
- Jalen Ramsey (CB) – Rams
- Sauce Gardner (CB) – Rams
- Pat Surtain II (CB) – Broncos
- Minkah Fitzpatrick (FS) – Steelers
- Derwin James Jr. (SS) – Chargers
Specialists (98 Overall)
- Austin Ekeler (3HB) – Chargers
- Kyle Juszczyk (FB) – 49ers
- Cameron Heyward (RE) – Steelers
- Nyheim Hines (KR) – Bills
- Justin Tucker (K) – Patriots
- Tommy Townsend (P) – Chiefs
NOW READ: All AKA The New Class Program Players – Madden 23 Ultimate Team
Madden 23 TOTY – Honorable Mentions
Down below, we’ve provided the Honorable Mentions from the TOTY selection that nearly made the cut. All of the TOTY Honorable Mentions come with 98 overall ratings and TOTY team chemistries as well.
Here’s the full list:
- Josh Allen (QB) – Bills
- Aaron Jones (HB) – Packers
- Ja’Mar Chase (WR) – Bengals
- George Kittle (TE) – 49ers
- Creed Humphrey (C) – Chiefs
- Myles Garrett (RE) – Browns
- Brian Burns (LE) – Panthers
- Jaire Alexander (CB) – Packers
- Marlon Humphrey (CB) – Ravens
Madden 23 TOTY – Player Nominees
As mentioned above, there were a total of 98 Nominees for the TOTY in Madden 23 Ultimate Team. In order to vote for the players, fans had to visit Madden 23’s TOTY Voting Countdown Page where each person had the opportunity to submit one set of TOTY votes per category.
There was a five day window for the TOTY Voting Period, that began on February 17, and ran until February 22. With the voting period over, Madden 23 Ultimate Team processed the votes and revealed the TOTY today, March 8, before its released in-game tomorrow, March 9.
Here’s the full list of all the TOTY Nominees in Madden 23 Ultimate Team:
Quarterbacks
- Patrick Mahomes – Chiefs
- Jalen Hurts – Eagles
- Joe Burrow – Bengals
- Josh Allen – Bills
- Justin Herbert – Chargers
- Justin Fields – Bears
Half Backs
- Josh Jacobs – Raiders
- Christian McCaffrey – 49ers
- Nick Chubb – Browns
- Saquon Barkley – Giants
- Jamal Williams – Lions
- Tony Pollard – Cowboys
Wide Receivers
- Justin Jefferson – Vikings
- Davante Adams – Raiders
- Tyreek Hill – Dolphins
- Jaylen Waddle – Dolphins
- A.J. Brown – Eagles
- Ja’Mar Chase – Bengals
- Stefon Diggs – Bills
- CeeDee Lamb – Cowboys
- Amon Ra-St. Brown – Lions
Tight Ends
- Travis Kelce – Chiefs
- George Kittle – 49ers
- Mark Andrews – Ravens
- T.J. Hockenson – Vikings
Offensive Line
- Jason Kelce (C) – Eagles
- Creed Humphrey (C) – Chiefs
- Frank Ragnow (C) – Lions
- Lane Johnson (RT) – Eagles
- Ryan Ramczyk (RT) – Saints
- Tristen Wirfs (RT) – Buccaneers
- Zack Martin (RG) – Cowboys
- Chris Lindstrom (RG) – Falcons
- Michael Onwenu (RG) – Patriots
- Joe Thuney (LG) – Chiefs
- Quentin Nelson (LG) – Colts
- Joel Bitonio (LG) – Browns
- Trent Williams (LT) – 49ers
- Andrew Thomas (LT) – Giants
- Christian Darrisaw (LT) – Vikings
Defensive Line
- Chris Jones (DT) – Chiefs
- Dexter Lawrence (DT) – Giants
- Quinnen Williams (DT) – Jets
- Derrick Brown (DT) – Panthers
- Maxx Crosby (LE) – Raiders
- Brian Burns (LE) – Panthers
- Jerry Hughes (LE) – Texans
- Nick Bosa (RE) – 49ers
- Myles Garrett (RE) – Browns
- Montez Sweat (RE) – Commanders
Outside Linebackers
- Micah Parsons (ROLB) – Cowboys
- Khalil Mack (ROLB) – Chargers
- Dre Greenlaw (ROLB) – 49ers
- Jaelan Phillips (ROLB) – Dolphins
- Haason Reddick (LOLB) – Eagles
- Matthew Judon (LOLB) – Patriots
- Danielle Hunter (LOLB) – Vikings
- Alex Highsmith (LOLB) – Steeles
Middle Linebackers
- Fred Warner – 49ers
- Lavonte David – Buccaneers
- Bobby Wagner – Rams
- Demario Davis – Saints
- Tremaine Edmunds – Bills
Cornerbacks
- Jalen Ramsey – Rams
- Sauce Gardner – Jets
- Jaire Alexander – Packers
- Stephon Gilmore – Colts
- Darius Slay Jr. – Eagles
- Marlon Humphrey – Ravens
- Patrick Surtain II – Broncos
- Charvarius Ward – 49ers
- Tyson Campbell – Jaguars
Safeties
- Minkah Fitzpatrick (FS) – Steelers
- Justin Simmons (FS) – Broncos
- Tyrann Mathieu (FS) – Saints
- Antoine Winfield (FS) – Buccaneers
- Kevin Byard (FS) – Titans
- Derwin James (SS) – Chargers
- Talanoa Hufanga (SS) – 49ers
- Budda Baker (SS) – Cardinals
- Ryan Neal (SS) – Seahawks
- Rodney McCloud (SS) – Colts
Specialists
- Austin Ekeler (3HB) – Chargers
- Aaron Jones (3HB) – Packers
- Jerick McKinnon (3HB) – Chiefs
- Kyle Juszczyk (FB) – 49ers
- Patrick Ricard (FB) – Ravens
- Alec Ingold (FB) – Dolphins
- Cameron Heyward (RDE) – Steelers
- Christian Wilkins (RDE) – Dolphins
- Javon Hargrave (RDE) – Eagles
- Nyheim Hines (KR) – Bills
- Jamal Agnew (KR) – Jaguars
- Keisean Nixon (KR) – Packers
- Justin Tucker (K) – Ravens
- Daniel Carlson (K) – Raiders
- Tommy Townsend (P) – Chiefs
- Braden Mann (P) – Jets
READ NOW: All Ultimate Legends Program Players & More – Madden 23 Ultimate Team
Madden 23 TOTY – Prediction
As we promised, down below we have our very own prediction of who we thought would make the Madden 23 Team Of The Year. These picks are based on how well these players performed over the 2022 regular and postseason (if applicable) as well as how consistently dominant they were.
So without another moment to spare, here’s our Madden 23 TOTY Prediction that was made on February 17, 2023:
Offense
- Joe Burrow (QB) – Bengals
- Josh Jacobs (HB) – Raiders
- Justin Jefferson (WR) – Vikings
- Davante Adams (WR) – Raiders
- Ja’Mar Chase (WR) – Bengals
- Travis Kelce (TE) – Chiefs
- Jason Kelce (C) – Eagles
- Lane Johnson (RT) – Eagles
- Zack Martin (RG) – Cowboys
- Joe Thuney (LG) – Chiefs
- Trent Williams (LT) – 49ers
Defense
- Nick Bosa (RE) – 49ers
- Dexter Lawrence (DT) – Giants
- Maxx Crosby (LE) – Raiders
- Micah Parsons (ROLB) – Cowboys
- Haason Reddick (LOLB) – Eagles
- Fred Warner (MLB) – 49ers
- Jalen Ramsey (CB) – Rams
- Sauce Gardner (CB) – Jets
- Stephon Gilmore (CB) – Colts
- Derwin James (SS) – Chargers
- Justin Simmons (FS) – Broncos
Specialists
- Austin Ekeler (3HB) – Chargers
- Kyle Juszczyk (FB) – 49ers
- Javon Hargrave (RDE) – Eagles
- Nyheim Hines (KR) – Bills
- Daniel Carlson (K) – Raiders
- Tommy Townsend (P) – Chiefs
This was our official prediction of what we thought the Madden 23 TOTY would look like. Some players that weren’t selected for this prediction, such as Patrick Mahomes and Chris Jones for example, were not chosen because they have already top-tier cards in MUT, particularly Mahomes.
No products found.