Final Fantasy XIV Online
A cinematic, narrative-based MMORPG that only lets you pick up a limited number of quests per day, stunts your experience points so you don't level too quickly, and is widely thought to be completely incomprehensible. Final Fantasy 14 leaves you wondering "wait, what am I meant to be doing now?" at every given opportunity. The response has been so negative that almost every aspect of the game is being patched in the next few months.