Brothers In Arms Hell's Highway

Brothers In Arms Hell's Highway Review for Xbox 360

On: Xbox 360PS3PC

Brothers In Arms Hell's Highway drops you into Operation Market-Garden, the largest airborne operation of World War II.

Review Verdict Read Review
8Out of 10
Back to game info

There's something peculiarly puzzling about gore in video games. Like chocolates in a box of Roses it can come in so many types. Gore can be completely stylised and over the top, like in upcoming black and white Wii game Mad World, for example. Or gore might be gritty and shocking, like in Grand Theft Auto IV.

Gore works in video games because of the context it appears in. The gritty and realistic gore in GTA 4 works because the tone of the game is realistic and gritty. The stylised and over the top gore in Mad Word works because the game is a complete parody of violence itself. In both cases because of the context of the games that the gore appears in, it's fine, it fits, and it's frikin' cool.

In World War II squad-based tactical first-person shooter Brothers in Arms: Hell's Highway, the best BiA, and Gearbox Software, game to date, the gore doesn't fit. Limbs tear off, faces explode and guts spill out onto the lovely virtual Dutch grass more often than in a two-part Quentin Tarantino movie. That's fine. WWII was, without a doubt, an incredibly gory experience for every soldier involved.

The problem, however, lies with the Action Camera. Whenever you score a head shot, or blow some Germans up with a grenade for example, the camera will zoom in and the action will slow down, showing you in glorious detail exploding faces and flying limbs. You can turn the Action Camera off in the options settings, thus eradicating these Action Camera Moments, as they're called, from the entire experience. But the damage has been done, and the game clearly makes no apology for their inclusion. In the Xbox 360 version (the version tested), you even get a couple of Achievements for them.

The slow motion Action Camera doesn't fits in the context of the rest of the game

The slow motion Action Camera doesn't fits in the context of the rest of the game

The only reason we have a problem with the Action Camera is because of the context of the rest of the game. Hell's Highway is based on an actual WWII Allied offensive, called Operation Market Garden, which aimed to carve a route up through occupied Holland and into Berlin, thus ending the war before Christmas 1944. The game focuses on the experiences of a squad of soldiers from the US 101st Airborne division, and, again, of BiA stalwart Sergeant Matt Baker. The series has always had a Band of Brothers feel to it, and in this, the third BiA game, the camaraderie theme has been ramped up even further. As you make your way through the meaty 10 chapter campaign, the story, told through cut scenes, details Baker's descent towards insanity as the war, and the responsibility of leading his men, takes its toll.

It's well voice acted, the dialogue is authentic, the sound effects superb and the soundtrack Hollywood quality. It's a well thought out, intelligent, sombre and honest interactive entertainment treatment on the life of a WWII solider, as well as a somewhat emotional portrayal of comradeship in the face of unspeakable horror. But it's because the game has reached these mature heights that the Action Camera jars so much. It ends up feeling like a feature that's been forced upon the game by some marketing team desperate to appeal to the Soldier of Fortune brigade.

For many this won't be a concern. For many the historical accuracy, the story, and the two Recon points scattered throughout each map (which unlock mini history lessons that detail the specifics of the operation) will play second fiddle to the kick ass WWII action. Here, Hell's Highway doesn't disappoint. In fact the combat reinforces the historical accuracy Gearbox has shot for perfectly.

It's all about the four Fs - find, fix, flank and finish. This strategy, actually employed during WWII, is one you'll need to master if you're going to finish the campaign, even on the casual setting. Say, for example, you're faced head-on with a German assault squad that's buried deep within solid cover. You could spend all day wasting ammunition playing Whac-A-Mole (that is, stay out of cover and wait for enemy heads to pop out - a strategy that works well up to about half the way through the game, after which you'll be torn to pieces). But the game wants you to think about your environment and the squads at your disposal to progress. There's no run and gun here - try it and you'll last a few seconds.

New stuff to check out

15 Comments

To add your comment, please login or register

User Comments

Steve's Avatar
Delete Post

Steve

This review is garbage. He acts like the action camera comes on everytime you shoot.
Posted 23:35 on 30 January 2009
matt baker's Avatar
Delete Post

matt baker

All the brothers games are good
Posted 00:27 on 30 January 2009
tonny white's Avatar
Delete Post

tonny white

this game is one of the best war games around imo. better than cod 4
Posted 12:26 on 01 January 2009
Rasta's Avatar
Delete Post

Rasta

I don't think this guy played the game that long. The AI is horrible in several places, most notably your squad often runs right into fire when directed to take cover. Enemy AI is also set to obvious triggers. This guy should actually play the game before sending out a BS review!!
Posted 17:20 on 30 December 2008
Fleef's Avatar
Delete Post

Fleef

I loved Earned In Blood and Road To Hill 30 because of the combat style; I hope this new one makes us of the same squad-based tactics. That's what set it apart from other war-based games. It's more strategic than just running around and shooting. My question: is this game worth the $60?
Posted 20:36 on 07 November 2008
uge's Avatar
Delete Post

uge

I bought mine today and it's great.
Better than the old ones. The only bad thing is that there's so little new stuff.
Posted 18:08 on 18 October 2008
Anonymous's Avatar
Delete Post

Anonymous

Seems like a good review, suppose we shall see shall we not? However I am partial to an exploding environment and a little brain use may be a good thing for a change!
Posted 14:51 on 06 October 2008
Kahm N. Since's Avatar
Delete Post

Kahm N. Since

This is fairly poorly written, but does contain some good information.
Posted 23:38 on 04 October 2008
Cam's Avatar
Delete Post

Cam

wtf? the action cam is awesome, and its not like it happens every ten seconds, i thought it was nice addition to the game where you can laugh at how brutal you are, and how wicked of a shot you just made.
Posted 23:09 on 28 September 2008
lastdual's Avatar
Delete Post

lastdual

I'm liking this a LOT more than COD2. Much more thoughtful action, plus you actually care about the characters.
Posted 17:54 on 26 September 2008
Ad's Avatar
Delete Post

Ad

Focusing on the gore/action cam as a downfall of the game is abit pathetic when it can easily be turned off. The review also complained about the controls being hard to get used to... why not just change it to the cod setting. Apart from that the review is v good.
Posted 12:12 on 25 September 2008
Anonymous's Avatar
Delete Post

Anonymous

Lush Im gonna get it
Posted 20:27 on 24 September 2008
infamousgaming's Avatar
Delete Post

infamousgaming

I've read many reviews about this game.. score is from 9 till 7.7 (IGN) .. I'm not sure if this is the game they have promised it would be..
Posted 14:21 on 24 September 2008
James's Avatar
Delete Post

James

Thanks for the review. I totally get your point about the gore/action cam. I'll be turning that off for sure - and can't wait to try Authentic without suppression icons (assuming that's still in the game)
Posted 09:39 on 24 September 2008
Anonymous's Avatar
Delete Post

Anonymous

Awesome. Cant wait
Posted 00:44 on 24 September 2008

Game Stats

Brothers In Arms Hell's Highway
8
Out of 10
Brothers In Arms Hell's Highway
  • Mature, intelligent story
  • Rewarding combat
  • Solid AI
  • Action Cam jars
Agree? Disagree? Get Involved!
Release Date: 26/09/2008
Platforms: Xbox 360 , PS3 , PC
Developer: Gearbox Software
Publisher: Ubisoft
Genre: First Person Shooter
Rating: BBFC 15
Site Rank: 1,500 8
View Full Site