As a first introduction to the world of Fables, the first episode of The Wolf Among Us was a fascinating beast. Moving away from the knee-jerk intensity of The Walking Dead to focus on something dramatically slower, it edged closer towards a TV show formula by trading interaction for an extra scoop of style.

The stunning cliffhanger we were left with last time seemed to set solid foundations in place, but after Episode 2 the future of the series doesn’t appear nearly as secure. The Smoke & Mirrors moniker sadly couldn’t be any more apt: Telltale has a gift for creating roller coasters that forge an unlikely illusion of control, but it’s a spell that fails to take hold here.

Episode 2 features no major decisions, focusing on small choices that boil down entirely to good-cop/bad-cop stuff. Be nice to a man, punch a man, try a bit of both. You’re reminded that characters will remember your decisions, but somehow that doesn’t feel like enough – the strings on the puppets seem obvious, giving you a sense that there’s a right and wrong way to approach any situation you face.

This is most notable in the crime scene sections, where the correct conversation choice is always the one that shows you have an understanding of what must have occurred. Without complex clues or red herrings in play, it all feels a bit Detective Fisher Price.

Stylish aesthetic and cinematic flair still keep the overall experience enjoyable, but my initial spark of love for the series has largely disappeared. After a shoddy narrative decision revealed within the first 15 minutes of Episode 2, my trust in the series has diminished. Shorter – and seemingly far less interactive – than what came before, the finale of Smoke & Mirrors will leave you wanting more, but it will also leave a slightly sour taste in your mouth.

Version Tested: PC. Completed in 2 hours.

New stuff to check out


To add your comment, please login or register

User Comments

Njeezy's Avatar


The season pass is currently not working on the xbox 360, it seems that anyone with a 360 is going to have to wait even longer before being able to continue the story.
Posted 18:30 on 05 February 2014
CyberEagle_1x's Avatar


When the The Wolf Among Us has finished, will you do a retrospective review? I like the slower build up with this game and I hope it ends on a good note. Its all about opinions and you made some good points. Good review Matt.
Posted 22:07 on 04 February 2014

Game Stats

Out of 10
The Wolf Among Us - Episode 2: Smoke & Mirrors
  • Enjoyable, if treated as being a more linear experience.
  • Undermined by a poor narrative choice.
  • No major decisions at all.
  • Good cop/bad cop choices are very black & white.
Agree? Disagree? Get Involved!
Release Date: 04/02/2014
Platforms: PC , Xbox 360 , PS3
Developer: Telltale Games
Publisher: Telltale Games
Genre: Adventure
Rating: TBC
Site Rank: 2,377 233
Check Price