Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots Review

For:PS3  Also On: Xbox 360 Release Date: 11 June 2008
Gekkos look awesome and are a deadly enemy
Gekkos look awesome and are a deadly enemy

Gekkos look awesome and are a deadly enemy

With stealth still being the core component of the game Snake has numerous tools at his disposal. These include a knife that can stun enemies, a tranquillizer gun, the MK II robot (ideal for scoping out areas while invisible) and a new OctoCamo suit that has chameleon-like properties. If Snake is still it will take on the appearance and texture of the surface it's next too. This is good enough to fool the naked eye and infra-red sensors. Your level of cover is displayed in the upper right corner of the screen, so you're always aware of how visible you are. During certain sections you'll have access to additional disguises and camouflage items, including a few that have been included for nostalgic purposes.

Avoiding enemies has always been a core component of the Metal Gear Solid series and it remains so here. If you're spotted the enemy will start actively pursuing you, so you need to get out of sight for long enough for the counter to count down to zero. If you're spotted during this time it'll hit 99 seconds again and you'll have to start the evasion from scratch.

Enemies vary a lot throughout the game, coming in all shapes and sizes, from the standard soldiers to the half robot, half animal Gekkos that can crush you if you're not careful. Bosses don't disappoint either, with those on offer being some of the most creatively designed I've ever seen in a video game. You can't simply shoot until their health bar is depleted either, with some thought required to pinpoint their weaknesses.

Once you've familiarised yourself with the nuances of the control scheme (which allows you to play the game in numerous ways - complete a level without killing anyone if you're good enough) the opening two thirds of the game are full of superb moments and thrilling gameplay. Things change from here on, though, with cut scenes suddenly taking up the majority of your time and the actual gameplay sections feeling rather disconnected from one another. As the game turns more and more into a movie things start to drag, and by the end I found it hard to give the game my full attention. There's no one cut scene that lasts too long, but at times they're joined together in a way that feels rather self indulgent. A boss fight near the end may well impress MGS devotees, but as a climax it felt woefully inadequate for such an epic game - but in keeping with its direction.

Much has been said about MGS4's visuals. From a technical point of view I wasn't blown away as much as I expected to be, mainly down to some rough texture work here and there and a frame rate that doesn't stay as smooth as I'd have liked. Despite this MGS4 easily competes with the best visuals consoles have produced, in no small part to the incredible design work in the game. MGS4 is a joy to play through, with some truly wonderful looking levels and enemy designs that quite frankly stand head and shoulders above what we see in most games. Cut scenes look incredible and for the most part offer some form of interactivity, but at times it's a shame you're having to watch some of the most action packed moments instead of playing in them.

MGS4 is a fitting last game to end the series

MGS4 is a fitting last game to end the series

When talking about the presentation the superb audio can't be overlooked. The use of surrounds is incredible and voice over work on the whole is on a level above the best we've heard. Having said that, at times some less than spectacular acting lets down key dramatic moments. One scene towards the end of the game fell completely flat as the actor failed to convey the emotion required. It's a small complaint in the grand scheme of things but one that stands out due to the cinematic feel.

Also included with MGS4 is Metal Gear Online, a team-based multiplayer game that will be expanded in the months to come. At the moment it's a great alternative to MGS4's single-player mode, although by no means for everyone. If you're expecting a standard online shooter, think again, or rather think again while re-spawning as you'll be shot dead rather quickly. By far the star of the online show is a sneaking game mode in which one player is Snake, another is the MK II and the rest are trying to hunt him down. This makes for some thrilling hunter/hunted gameplay, with superb support options available to the MK II player - invisible electrocution is always fun. With a selection of other team-based modes and plenty of players on the servers, MGO should have quite a future. It is worth noting that only one character is allowed per console. If a second player requires their own character it'll cost you money.

Metal Gear Solid 4 had a lot to live up to and it's done so brilliantly. It's a game that will go down in history as one of the most ambitious and cinematic ever made, but also, finally, and more importantly, it will go down as a MGS game with gameplay that doesn't polarise opinion. It's not without it problems, most notably in the change of pace in the last third and the often laborious cut scenes (if you could play even half of the best cinematic moments MGS4 would wipe the floor with the best games we've ever seen), but MGS fans won't care. Although unquestionably a game everyone should play, when you're forced to take the back seat the blurred line between a game and movie prevents MGS4 from being the 10/10 masterpiece we hoped it would be.

VideoGamer.com Score

9Score out of 10
  • Stunning presentation
  • Awesome audio
  • Refined controls
  • Some cut scenes drag

New stuff to check out

To add your comment, please login or register

User Comments

Schumey's Avatar

Schumey

I hate how you just try to find flaws in MGS4. An 8 for gameplay, huh? That's probably the one aspect where MGS4 excelled the most. Gameplay has never been so smooth before!
Long cutscenes? They can be paused and skipped, so get over it! At least they're well worth watching!
MGS4 is the finest gaming experience you'll find this generation. Too bad VideoGamer didn't get the message.
Posted 08:47 on 03 June 2010
thpcplayer's Avatar

thpcplayer

i just love this game!
Posted 12:44 on 29 December 2009
KANE_AND_LYNCH's Avatar

KANE_AND_LYNCH

Iv been playing the MGS series sents the very 1st one for the Nintendo (actualy i still have it and yes i still play) i enjoyed this tittle alot what konami needs to do is creat them all on the next gen console (PS3) and sell them all in a bundle pack it would be quite expensive to do but it cost quite alot too like charge 250$ for the bundle with the for the nintendo to MGS3. (Id buy it)!
Posted 02:52 on 07 April 2009
Ronny's Avatar
Delete Post

Ronny

Just have to say something about the frame rate issue and texture.

Yes i admit im a fan, but what on earth?. I playd trough MGS4 and i havent notice any kind of frame rate issue or texture prob. Are u sure u havent playd trough the game with a HD tv on 1080p?(reviewer). Cause if u done so it will cause some weird frame issues. I playd Gears of war 2 on a 1080p HD tv, and i almost puked after 15min, cause of the FPS. wich where 30 i belive, 720p has 60fps. Makes evrything go a lot smoother. Cause i dont understand at all how MGS4 had any frame rate issues or texture for that matter. Cause i dident notice anything at all, and im quite sensitiv to these things. The game is still the best looking game to date on PS3, so it deserve 10graphic wise.

True the Cinematic can get a bit to long sometimes, but i ges thats why the game always create a bond with the player cause of the cinematics. 1 of the reasons LOTR got big, cause the movies was so long, it gave people more time to love the characters. 10hours+ or something total time of LOTR, The whole MGS genre has certainly a lot more^^.
Story is great. And complex with many twists and turns that keeps u intrested:).
Gameplay is great, heck they started a new unqiue playing style.
Music always great.
Certainly 10 overall:).
Posted 11:56 on 11 February 2009
safc's Avatar

safc

this game is a very cool game, if you like MGS games you will love this game also a bonus to this game is that it has online gameplay which is mint. I love the story mode on it too and im glad how it ends, but i wont say because i dont want to spoil it for you if you havnt played on it before. So my advice is buy this game!!!!!
Posted 09:25 on 11 February 2009
Gabriel's Avatar
Delete Post

Gabriel

@Sylencer

Are you sure you played the same game as the rest of the world ?
The writing in MGS4 is absolutely fenomenal, richly layered and allegorical. It is so much beyond anything in this medium and quite on par with some of the most thought provoking novels, movies & TV dramas out there.
Of course, seeing how some think that writing like: "Brucie likes pussy" is good writing or movies like Spiderman or Ironman are considered good movies, then God help us all.
Posted 11:58 on 03 February 2009
Ra1den's Avatar

Ra1den

It's a huge game.there is no doubt in it.

world of gow2 is just more detailed than gow1. Mgs4's best on PS3
Posted 09:15 on 22 November 2008
Yup's Avatar
Delete Post

Yup

Someone said Gears looks better? Are you joking? There's a little thing called variety...MGS4 has it, and Gears is almost entirely composed of one color.
Posted 17:08 on 05 October 2008
CJW's Avatar
Delete Post

CJW

METAL GEAR SOLID 4 IS MINT MINT MINT MGS ONLINE ALSO ROCKS PS3 BEST GAME BY MILES
Posted 11:16 on 05 August 2008
CJW's Avatar
Delete Post

CJW

Mgs 4 is mint best game i have ever played great great great !!!! it rocks
Posted 11:12 on 05 August 2008
Final_Rpg's Avatar
Delete Post

Final_Rpg

You gave Halo a 10? But not this? You shouldn't be allowed to have a keyboard. Honestly, don't review games anymore, your not worthy. I'm still in awe to how bias you are. Seems every game that deserves a 10 is either multiplatform or on 360. Your pathetic, no respect for true masterpieces. Gameplay an 8? 20 hour experience plus MGO sounds like infinite replay value to me.
Posted 16:00 on 24 July 2008
COLE ZOBEL's Avatar
Delete Post

COLE ZOBEL

WHY IS THERE NO TALK ABOUT MGS4/ONLINE PLAY?





Posted 08:08 on 04 July 2008
ehutch's Avatar
Delete Post

ehutch

there are NO frame rate issues in mgs4 and the textures are impressive. this is the best looking game ever to grace a console period. the dialogue is a bit long winded but i am really enjoying this game. i was initially put off by the news of long cut scenes and almost passed up on the purchase but the story is great although confusing, production values are through the roof, this game is really something special. i wigh it were longer though. anyone criticizing the graphics are just a JEALOUS XBOT FANBOY. thats a fact.
Posted 02:43 on 28 June 2008
DanteUY's Avatar
Delete Post

DanteUY

I"m sorry, just what kind of mind-blowing visuals were you expecting? Every rock, every bombed-out building, even the blades of grass and tall weeds you can hide in were flawless and realistic. Physics of characters, vehicles, even the fact that when you go from a bright to a dark environment it takes a moment or two to have Snake's eyes adjust to the change. Those "laborious" cut scenes also yield rewards-- hidden views, flashbacks that net more Drebin points if you're on your toes... clearly you are one of those that fall into the "God, why can't I skip the story and just kill things" player. If that's your way of thinking, then please, go back to your CoD and GoW. You're not welcome in a storyteller's paradise.
*********
This guy knows his sh*t, unlike the reviewer.
Posted 15:45 on 23 June 2008
Handwipe's Avatar

Handwipe

I just finished the game about 10 min ago, and I think the review is pretty solid. The graphics are good but not that amazing. I was a lot more impressed with Gears of War two years ago. The story is unequaled though. This game is such a crazy cinematic experience. Everyone who calls themselves gamers should play through it just to see what all the hype is about. The cut-scenes are really top-notch and set the bar for all future story-driven games. And the action in the set-piece battles are just mind-blowing.

Having said that, it is a stretch to call MGS4 a videogame. It's more like a 20 hour interactive movie. The reviewer states that the last third of the game does not have much gameplay in relation to cutscenes but in reality only the first couple acts of the game have any actual lengthy gameplay bits. I won't spoil anything but from the start of the last act to the end of the game contains literally about 20-30 mins of gameplay including boss battles and maybe about 2 hours of cutscenes. There were 3 times during the game that I had to pause the cutscene and take a nap because my eyes were getting too heavy and I didn't want to miss any important parts of the story. The acting wasn't that great either, with the cutscenes getting increasingly more over-acted and sappy towards the end of the game. Sometimes it was really pathetic. But they make up for it with amazing action sequences and some cut-scenes that are more fun to watch than movies. I found myself disappointed when they ended and I had to play again because the gameplay in MGS4 is honestly not very good. It doesn't even come close to competing with other next-gen games in the gameplay department. Playing was more of a chore than fun.

Overall it was worth the time I put in and I think everyone should experience it, at least rent it. Just make sure you have pop-corn ready before hand and don't expect much of a game.
Posted 01:46 on 23 June 2008

Game Stats

Go to Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots PlayStation 3 Game Index

Review Summary: Metal Gear Solid 4 had a lot to live up to and it's done so brilliantly. It will go down in history as one of the most ambitious and cinematic ever made.

Our Score: 9 out of 10
Developer: Konami
Publisher: Konami
Genre: Stealth
No. Players: 1 + Online
Rating: BBFC 15
Site Rank: 357 17