BioShock Review

For:PS3  Also On: Xbox 360PC Release Date: 16 October 2008
We'd have liked to have seen more changes in the PS3 version
We'd have liked to have seen more changes in the PS3 version

We'd have liked to have seen more changes in the PS3 version

Your first experience with a Plasmid - a genetically-altering pack made from ADAM which grants you a super power of sorts - arrives almost as soon as you step out of the dripping wet bathysphere and into the crumbling walls of the city. Plasmids were sold to the citizens of Rapture as harmless, life-improving packs of pleasure. But Plasmids have a nasty side-effect - they drive users mad and are incredibly addictive. In many ways all of Rapture's problems can be laid squarely at the door of Andrew Ryan's Plasmids.

The Plasmids make BioShock much more than a straight-up shooter. Electrobolt, for example, shocks Splicers in place, allowing you to 'one-two punch' them to death with your wrench. But you can also use it to electrocute multiple enemies who are standing in water. Enrage makes foes so angry that they'll attack the person nearest to them, friend or foe. Taking on a Big Daddy is tough, but it's a lot easier with a pack of enraged Splicers backing you up. There's even a Telekinesis Plasmid, which allows you to grab objects with your mind and use them as weapons. A Molotov cocktail-throwing Nitro Splicer becomes a less fearsome foe when you can throw its fiery grenades back at him.

There are loads of Plasmids in BioShock (the PS3 version comes with the new Plasmids that were made available via DLC for the Xbox 360 version) and as you progress through Rapture's captivating innards you'll pick up more and more of them, opening up your options when it comes to taking on enemies. Eventually Rapture itself evolves into a playground for you to enjoy and the Splicers become your playthings for you to experiment with as you combine Plasmids with the environment to cause murderous mayhem. Well, it's you or them, isn't it?

But BioShock's true brilliance lies in the way Rapture tells the story of its own demise. Elaborately designed post-murder scenes and well-placed scribbles on the city walls paint a picture more striking than a thousand cut scenes. Discarded audio logs (a gameplay mechanic Irrational Games, now 2K Boston, pioneered with the System Shock games) unravel the secret of the city's demise, and fill you with horror at what's ahead of you. You'll come to dread your encounter with Rapture's insane plastic surgeon, for example, not because you've seen him cut up terrified 'patients' in cut scenes, but because you've listened to him attempt to rationalise his work via his personal logs and seen the fallout first hand on bloodstained walls and in ghoulish, disfigured female corpses you half expect to rise from their battered operating tables. It's a completely and utterly terrifying mechanic, wonderfully executed.

The DLC looks promising, but we don't know when it'll be released.

The DLC looks promising, but we don't know when it'll be released.

BioShock is in many ways the perfect single-player video game. Atmospheric, creepy, thought-provoking and inspiring, it's the perfect antidote for those tired of the trash-talking lobbies of online shooters. The only reason BioShock doesn't get a perfect 10 is because the game falls away quite dramatically towards the end, as we've mentioned. But it misses out only by the skin of its genetically altered teeth. Some critics have pointed to the Vita-Chamber 'issue' as a critical flaw. These resurrection points effectively make death meaningless in that they respawn you after you've died with the damage you've done to enemies intact and a boost to your EVE meter (used to power Plasmid use). But you can turn them off if you're in the mood for masochism. Or you could try the new PS3-exclusive Survivor difficulty mode, which makes enemies much tougher to kill, every resource scarcer, and Vita-Chambers less generous with the EVE replenishment. So hard is it in fact, that you have to think about how you're going to use each and every one of your Plasmids to survive every encounter. No longer can you run about bashing everything with your powered-up wrench. And if you want all of the Trophies, you're going to have to get used to it - one is awarded for beating the game on Survivor.

If you're a PS3 owner and you've never played BioShock, you owe it to yourself to run out to the shops right now, hand over your hard earned cash, run home and spend the rest of the weekend with the lights, your mobile, and attention to family, friends and loved ones well and truly turned off. If you're a PS3 owner and you have played BioShock, perhaps finished it, perhaps not, then we can't really recommend you fork out the £40 or so it'll cost you to play the game again. We know next to nothing about the upcoming PS3-exclusive Challenge Rooms, which won't be out in time for release but will be out before the end of the year as downloadable content (expect a hands-on preview very soon), so can't in good conscience suggest picking up the game for that reason alone. If you're obsessed with BioShock, you might think it worth it for the Survivor difficulty mode, but for us, it's not.

Overall, BioShock is still as powerful an interactive experience as it was a year ago. It's lost none of its freshness, its newness or its impact. It's the thinking man's shooter and poster boy for the 'games are art' brigade. On PS3 it still is. For many BioShock was 2007's game of the year. How funny that for PS3 owners it might be 2008's.

VideoGamer.com Score

9Score out of 10
  • Approach situations in different ways
  • Superb atmosphere
  • Just as good as it was
  • Changes are minimal

New stuff to check out

Comments

To add your comment, please login or register

User Comments

Anonymous's Avatar
Delete Post

Anonymous

played and loved both versions of bioshock on the xbox 360 and ps3 plus overall i feel the ps3 version edges it,higher resolution textures in places and much better blurring effects if anything via hdmi the ps3 version looks more photo realistic.Ultimetly its about gameplay though and 2k gave it back to the people when they released this classic that will be talked about and played in years to come.
Posted 15:14 on 03 December 2008
NerdyMcGamer's Avatar

NerdyMcGamer

I loved this game! It's been a long time since I've played a game till I had circles under my eyes! After 6 hours of continuous play, one night, I felt like a splicer myself. It's too bad I had to wait a year to get it! Yes, I'm a Playstation fanboy...or actually fangirl. Sorry boys.
Posted 04:24 on 03 November 2008
TomO's Avatar

TomO

360 and PS3 were captured via HDMI at 720p.
Posted 09:29 on 20 October 2008
MikeHochensach's Avatar

MikeHochensach

I'm dying to know at what resolution the ps3 side of the Bioshock comparison video shot at. I'm furious with 2k for producing a half assed port given 14 months of extra development time. Your video as well as all the screenshots I have seen show that the ps3 version is inferior in the texture department. Now 2k fanboys are claiming in their forums that the comparison video you made doesn't count because it was shot using a 1080p feed for the ps3 side. I think they are just making that up, and would love to know the truth. Thank you in advance.
Posted 23:24 on 19 October 2008
RecoN's Avatar

RecoN

Fanboy's are booooooooring! PC wipes the console version's hands down :D The gameplay is easier than a controller, easier to select plasmids etc. 9 for consoles and 10 for PC, but that is due to sharper gfx on PC. But mainly the game play is better!
Posted 16:46 on 17 October 2008
Karlius's Avatar

Karlius

I'd have given it a point less too its a whole year on and games should advance and not stay stagnent. We have also had a load more games to compare this one too. Well done Wes on another Honest Review. And yes SteakPieHarry there seems to be a load of these fanboys stinking up the place. 9 is a great score!
Posted 16:26 on 17 October 2008
SteakPieHarry's Avatar
Delete Post

SteakPieHarry

More idiotic Sony fanboys stinking up the site. Take your bile elsewhere. It's getting boring.
Posted 15:52 on 17 October 2008
avid reader's Avatar
Delete Post

avid reader

Nice to hear a PS3 Port that has been given some care and attention,
Posted 15:08 on 17 October 2008
Putty Man's Avatar
Delete Post

Putty Man

Good review, I'd day this game was morre a solid 8/10 for me (only played it on XBox). I can see why people give it a 9 tho as the atmosphere it creates is second to none.

Also +1 to Mike, no need to back yourself up against crazy fanboys. Tho they do provide a lot of clicks on a lot of video gaem websites throughout the world ;-).
Posted 12:50 on 17 October 2008
Mike's Avatar
Delete Post

Mike

No need to explain yourselfs to the fanboys they would moan even if it was a 10

At the end of the day it was released ages ago on the 360 and there has been loads of good games which have came out between then and now which have set the bar of what is considered a "10" game.
Posted 11:59 on 17 October 2008
wyp100's Avatar

wyp100

For me, BioShock is a 9/10 game. If I had reviewed the Xbox 360 version I would have given it 9/10 as well. The Xbox 360 version was reviewed by Greg, who no longer works for us. This review is entirely my own opinion.

Also, the PS3 version of GTA 4 got a 10/10, as it did on Xbox 360.
Posted 11:27 on 17 October 2008
RecoN's Avatar

RecoN

Mate its a PS3 game, they dont get 10's on this site! Get use to it :S
Posted 10:50 on 17 October 2008
El-Dev's Avatar

El-Dev

This is a joke, how can the same game be given a lower score, oh right it Wesley doin the review. As for it being the PS3 game of the year, how funny you forgot MGS4, I know you won't like it cause it's not on 360, or little big planet.
Posted 09:55 on 17 October 2008

Game Stats

Go to BioShock PlayStation 3 Game Index

Review Summary: Overall, BioShock is still as powerful an interactive experience as it was a year ago. It's lost none of its freshness, its newness or its impact.

Our Score: 9 out of 10
Developer: 2K Boston
Publisher: 2K Games
Genre: First Person Shooter
No. Players: One
Rating: BBFC 18
Site Rank: 1,523 100