The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim - Dragonborn screenshot
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim - Dragonborn screenshot

Despite what I have often said, 2012 has not been a bad year for games. Much to the contrary, actually; when pushed, I will usually try and elaborate and say that 2012 has been a bad year for traditional boxed games, the ones played traditionally on consoles.

Except, of course, that hasn't really been the case either (provided you're not looking at the UK sales numbers). Just last week Bethesda released a grand content-stuffed add-on for The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, last year's King of the Boxed Game, and if that's not enough to get you incredibly excited then you probably aren't that keen on Skyrim. But that's okay! There is almost certainly something new, rich and exciting on a shelf waiting for you: Borderlands 2, Halo 4, Far Cry 3, Dishono(u)red, Max Payne 3 - all fine examples of boxed games delivering the kind of whizzy experience boxed games absolutely should. Bravo!

Why, then, has this malaise afflicted me? I suppose there's been a string of painful disappointments from plenty of other big-budget games, and the sense I'm being repeatedly sold the same experience time and time again feels particularly gruelling this year. This is truly an industry that lives on games where you shoot people with guns, and in the past few years I have shot an awful lot of people. Perhaps I am tired. So very tired.

Still, the unrest runs quite a bit deeper than the fact games like Hitman: Absolution and Resident Evil 6 were cack. There's also been (and this sounds incredibly vague) a certain feeling. Plenty of people think it's because they're tired of Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 and they want next-gen hardware, but I'm not sure it's that either. If you ask me, my ill sentiment towards much of this year's output is because I am desperate for new experiences in gaming - and, if you'll allow me to suggest it, those desired experiences must be far more than just the same old shooters being whizzed up with another layer of technology, or cherished old franchises being run through the Call of Duty training academy.

Still. I have been grumpy this year, but I probably shouldn't have. Case in point: one of the best things about the last few years of the games industry has been the proliferation of new ways to play games. My stand-out highlight of 2012 has been Valve's Dota 2, a game ineligible for our Game of the Year award due to the fact it's (despite me investing over 150 hours in it already) not actually out yet. That's a funny old situation to be in, of course, and it casts a particularly gloomy eye over traditional gaming media, and the very concept of a Game of the Year award itself, in a medium that's rapidly seeing an influx of connected, evolving services as opposed to things you stick in a box and dust off when it comes to that time in December when we need to start posturing.

hitman605 -

Despite Dota 2 being my personal be-all and end-all (while writing this I am also engaged in an e-mail chain about establishing a serious Dota 2 team, no joke), this canny strategy title represents plenty of things people are currently afraid of. It's free-to-play and fuelled by microtransactions, although Valve wisely opts to make its premium content purely cosmetic. It's also online only, eschewing the kind of single-player experience most of in our twenties are so used to. Microtransactions! Free to play! Online only! These are the kind of things that plenty of us are currently terrified of, and not without good reason - there are plenty of exploitative free-to-play games out there. But I think it's worth asserting that not every company making free-to-play is Zynga, and not every free-to-play game is obnoxious, money-grabbing guff.

While these ideas of change will upset many, I don't think it's something to be particularly feared. Let's not forget that digital distribution - a concept now warmly received - was a thorny, contentious unknown at the launch of the Xbox 360. If you had told somebody in June 2005, as they no doubt celebrated Tony Blair winning his third term, that come December they'd be having far more fun playing the 400MSP Geometry Wars on their £280 Xbox 360 than they would that £50 copy of Perfect Dark Zero, well, their head probably would have exploded at the sheer madness of it all.

Digital, by way of things like outrageously priced indie bundles, competitive sales and predominantly the iPhone, has also inadvertently ushered in an era where we expect to be paying less (if anything) for our games. One of the things I hear people say a lot is that that these newfangled ways of peddling games will come at the detriment of traditional single-player experiences, though I don't really buy it. The idea certainly makes for a juicy, salacious talking point, but if anything it's our grand, bold and successful single-player games that make life harder for other single-player games. Everything in our medium is getting bigger, from the swelling audiences to the rising development costs and, crucially, the expectations of length for our big-budget boxed games. Skyrim, which is such a lovely, dense and rich adventure, is also a massive blockbuster which continues to pad itself out with additional content, even if Dawnguard and Hearthfire were a bit crappy. Bethesda's epic is now such a time commitment that many of us didn't actually need to be ingratiating ourselves into dozens of single-player universes every month. Trying to exist in Tamriel, Amalur and the Northern Kingdoms at the start of 2012 was basically an impossible feat.

I haven't even mentioned the inescapable attraction of some of 2012's wonderful, creative digital titles. Hotline Miami, Journey, Trials Evolution – bliss. I think I'm playing games for as much time as I always have, but at the same time I think I'm playing far fewer games now than I did three or four years ago.

Time is another key commodity that's easy to forget. Increasing demands on our time, and from a swelling source of options, will obviously have an effect on gaming over the next few years, and the ramifications of publishers trying to transition their games into services will start to be felt over the coming months. My money is on most publishers doubling down on their signature franchises at the expense of a wide range of games, and while such sentiment will have a chilling effect on the financial cogs that power the current state of the industry I don't see this as a particularly bad thing for gamers.

Resident Evil 6 screenshot

Much of the traditional games industry - publishers, developers and media - are sitting anxiously in the hope that the triumphant reveal of new console hardware will both revitalise an industry and return it to how things used to be. I sincerely doubt the arrival of new Xbox and PlayStation will trigger a renaissance of the games industry circa 2007, but we shouldn't want it to. In the end, I like to think of these new ways of playing, and the tantalising prospect of what the future can bring us, as ways to enhance games as opposed to a replacement for what we've been used to.

I have felt disappointed by games in 2012, then, but maybe that's because I've spent too much time thinking about the wrong games. There's been plenty of disappointing muck over the last year, but these are disruptive, exciting times, and while I believe certain publishers, developers and media outlets might struggle to keep up, the games we are playing and the ways we play them are only going to get better.

New stuff to check out


To add your comment, please login or register

User Comments

Wido's Avatar


GTA V is about the only game that I really want. Of course there are others, but, GTA V has my attention. I will be playing GTA IV again before it launches.
Posted 22:59 on 29 December 2012
Mintyrebel's Avatar

Mintyrebel@ Clockpunk

Where is the love for Routine!? I can't wait for that damn game!
Posted 21:45 on 29 December 2012
87Sarah's Avatar


Great article thanks Martin.

I've noticed that for me, the more open world the game is, the more I seem to enjoy it.
Skyrim has taken up so much of my gaming time this year I think it's fair to say that it has overtaken FFVII as my favourite game in the world ever! It's sheer scale of the game and endless list of things to do that I look for in new titles. Spending £40 on a game that lasts 10 hours just isn't right.
I'm not the type of person that will play through a game more than once, no matter how many times I enjoy it either.

This year I have been tempted a few times to dip into the genre of MMO's for the first time, and you are right, it scares the living daylights out of me.
My attitude towards all online gaming is a little sketchy. I have had a lot of experiences where people find loopholes and ways they can cheat at online gaming so that it becomes an unenjoyable experience for a lot of people. that really puts me off, especially racing games. You also get the hardcore players in FPS that will annihilate everyone in their path, which is fine if you are any where near their level. I wish online FPS had difficulty levels so you could choose whether you wanted to have your ass handed to you or not. Mind you, people would take advantage of that too.

I haven't tried an MMO because I don't want to pay and find out I don't like it. I don't want to find out that I become terribly addicted and can think of nothing else. I want to still give myself some time to play new games and I don't want people handing my ass to me!

Maybe a massive open world Skyrim type game with a hint of MMO or social aspect thrown in would be my kind of thing.
Posted 21:41 on 29 December 2012
Londongirl1's Avatar


GTA V and Bioshock are top of my list!
Posted 13:16 on 29 December 2012
MJTH's Avatar

MJTH@ Clockpunk

Agreed, I am looking forward to the many more indie games coming out next year then boxed retail games:

A hat in time, Dysis, Flightless, Maker's Tale, Purge, No Time to Explain (steam release), Mercenary Kings, Sealark, Strike Suit Zero, Rainfall: the Sojourn, Godus, Scroll Ninja, Starbound, Planetary Annihilation... Etc

That's to say I'll buy all of them, but I'm following their progress.

Of course there is Fire Emblem and Lego City to look forward to on the retail game space, but other then those two game I'm not sure what other boxed game I'll buy. Maybe Rayman legend or Luigi's Mansion. And probably PLvsAA.
Posted 10:10 on 25 December 2012
reynoldio's Avatar

reynoldio@ Chris78A

What's a nex genn?

Posted 07:36 on 25 December 2012
Chris78A's Avatar


2012 was dissapointing for me as it was the first time i'd really wished for the next gen to hurry up. Whether it was because shooting games have been done so much this gen, or that casual 'phone' games dont feel like proper video games, I dont know. Either way next year will be interesting to see if the video game market (digital and physical) starts to stall.
Posted 00:17 on 25 December 2012
Clockpunk's Avatar


As I mentioned in another thread, it is (surprisingly enough) smaller scale indie PC games that have my interest piqued for 2013 - War for the Overworld, Sir You Are Being Hunted, Starbound, Don't Starve, to name but a few - and the ongoing updates and additions to MineCraft.

Of course, GTA V will get a good look-in, but that is the only triple-A title currently grabbing my attention (like everyone else)
Posted 17:47 on 24 December 2012
FantasyMeister's Avatar


I think next year will be interesting for three reasons:

Grand Theft Auto V.
Whether or not OUYA can survive and all the ramifications for alternative funding models.
E3 can only get better.

For me it'll be a year of catch up on the backlog, something I intended to do this year but failed miserably because I added more AAA titles to my collection than most previous years, including Borderlands 2, Far Cry 3 and Halo 4. Far Cry 3 alone has clocked up 196 hours on Raptr in just 25 days and I probably have 30 or 40 titles that warrant similar attention in my pile of things to do.
Posted 17:32 on 24 December 2012
rbevanx's Avatar


Yeah I pretty much agree about the year with let downs on AAA games like Assassin's Creed 3, Max Payne 3 and Dishoured (I'm glad I'm not the only one who hates the spelling of it) for me. But arcade games is where it's been for me with my top 3 for the year all being arcade games.
I did really like Spec Ops, Prototype 2 and Halo 4 with this years AAA games though, but yeah in general very poor year for them.

I think 2013 will actually be better with Dead Space 3 and the new Aliens game coming out early with The Last of Us and Beyond also looking promising.
But in all honesty I think current gen is starting to get far too old and some new consoles are needed to expand on current franchises or try something very different.
Posted 16:01 on 24 December 2012
reynoldio's Avatar


Nice article, cheers Martin. I agree with everything except, personally, for your initial position. I thought 2012 was pretty good! Everything you've written still counts: there were disappointments; boxed games weren't frequently spectacular; downloads and F2P did some good stuff, just that my first thought is undoubtedly positive.

I enjoyed Borderlands 2 loads and had anticipated it greatly. Ditto ME3 at the start of the year. I've loved playing my Vita in the odd moment and even though there aren't exactly loads of great games, there is enough to keep a 32 year old new father busy. Journey was one of my greatest moments in gaming, ever. Might as well say 'ditto ME3' again. X-COM wasn't a game I vividly remember, for some reason it passed me by, but my word I enjoyed XCOM. Throw the brilliance I just knew I'd love like Football Manager 13 and Need for Speed: Most Wanted into the mix and you've got an excellent year.

Again, I agree, not that much that absolutely jumps off the page, but plenty of genuine entertainment. And I haven't played The Walking Dead yet.

Here's to 2013 being just as disappointing ;)
Posted 15:47 on 24 December 2012

Related Games

Dota 2

Dota 2
Available For: PC Genre: Unknown Score9

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Available For: Xbox 360, PS3, PC Genre: RPG Score9

Resident Evil 6

Resident Evil 6
Available For: Xbox 360, PS3, PC, PS4, Xbox One Genre: Third-person shooter Score6

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim - Dawnguard

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim - Dawnguard
Available For: Xbox 360, PS3, PC Genre: RPG Score7

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim - Hearthfire

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim - Hearthfire - No boxshot available.
Available For: Xbox 360 Genre: Unknown Score4

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim - Dragonborn

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim - Dragonborn
Available For: Xbox 360, PS3, PC Genre: First person RPG Score8

View Full Site