Ever played a really good video game and then immediately thought: I'd love to play this again, only different and not anywhere near as good? Of course you have: after all, why would developers keep changing franchises for the worse? Oh. Money. Right. In light of Dead Space 3 not living up to expectations, here are some of the other worst offenders...

Super Mario Brothers 2

mariobros2nes -

After the industry-saving majesty of Super Mario Brothers, it's safe to say the world was unbelievably pumped for the sequel. All Nintendo had to do was deliver more of the same. And it did, in Japan. What the rest of the world got was something that caused more Nintendo-based tears than the Wind Waker reveal and the whole Wii era combined.

The problem was quite simple: it wasn't actually a SMB game as we knew it. Nintendo knew this of course – we're not suggesting the firm is that stupid, even if it did make the Virtual Boy. Nope, Nintendo had thought that real SMB 2 was 'too hard', which – in an era for video games when actually completing one was accepted as alternate entry credit for the British SAS – was probably a bit much.

So it took a game called Doki Doki Panic, put Mario characters in it, and laughed all the way to the bank. It's not a bad game: it's just very different. Fortunately, Super Mario Brothers 3 soon made it all better.

Resident Evil 6

Resident Evil 6 screenshot

In March 2012 Capcom producer Masachika Kawata admitted that the user base for survival horror titles was too small, and so the series would have to continue to borrow from more action-oriented games to compete with, essentially, CoD. Which is remarkably ambitious/silly, but hey: Resident Evil 4 had done the business. Why couldn't this?

Sadly, Resi 6 didn't try to just take from the action genre: it attempted to be every game ever made at once. We're surprised there wasn't a football mini-game in there. Or an RTS where you had to fight to control the valuable resources responsible for maintaining Leon's luscious locks.

There was survival horror, and Gears-style action, and some underwhelming fighting nonsense – from the firm that gave us Street Fighter II, no less – and then it was like Uncharted for a while, and a bit like Call of Duty, and by the end of it you have to wonder if it was all some elaborate joke. It wasn't. It was instead a disjointed package of good moments from better games rendered worse. We weren't the only ones that were disappointed, and Kawata himself has 'revised' his opinion of the series' action focus.

Def Jam: Icon

defjamiconscreenshot 2 -

Icon's predecessor, Def Jam: Fight For New York, may well be the greatest game ever made. Don't believe us? Well how about this: it was developed by AKI (along with EA Chicago – more on that later), the team behind the excellent N64 WCW wrestling titles, only this time you could push Sean Paul in front of a train. Exactly.

In fairness, there was a lot of pressure on Def Jam Icon because of the aforementioned Paul-train interfacing. So when AKI exited the series, leaving EA Chicago in sole charge, the developer made the sensible choice to dial back the wrestling and make the environment bounce to the beat of the song you're listening to. What?

It gets really silly from there on out. The idea was that you could change the beat of the backing track, and in doing so deal more damage by striking foes into the environment to 'your' song. (Sadly, not the Elton John track).

Part music game, part fighter, all nonsense, Icon tried to piggyback on the rhythm-action craze and failed. Fighting was fiddly, changing track in the middle of a fight was irritating, and the combat itself wasn't up to par. We're still waiting for the true sequel to Fight For New York. It may be some time.

Manhunt 2

Manhunt 2 screenshot

Infamous for initially being banned for its ultraviolent content, the crusty old deans at the BBFC would have done us a favour if it had stayed that way. Instead it was censored and released, and isn't very good. At all.

Why? Because it validates all of the nonsense criticism of the first game.

The original Manhunt may have been violent, but it always explored the relationship between violence and the player. Most wouldn't want to stick a shard of glass (or whatever else) into people's eyes but when you have to – the snuff film director you're trapped by won't let you proceed if you don't kill – you have to. It's a clever way of asking players how far they are ready to go to 'win'.

In Manhunt 2, you kill people to bits because – wahey – you're simply 'mad'. Or something. The result is violence for violence's sake, which becomes really boring, really quickly. In actuality, you'll be insane to play through to the end.

Red Faction Armageddon

Red Faction Armageddon screenshot

We love Volition here at VideoGamer. LOVE THEM. They make awesome games. But then they also made this, a sequel which took one of its predecessor's biggest draws – the open world – and did away with it, replacing it with a rather more pedestrian, linear setting. Which would kind of be like if GTA V did away with the city and instead only gave you one straight road to drive down, like a hyper-advanced Desert Bus.

The lovely destruction engine still remained, but with the sense of alien, explorative wonder gone – and no massive bridges to destroy – this was a poor attempt to chase the Gears of War dollar. It bombed, predictably. But hey: there's always Saints Row.

Deus Ex: Invisible War

invisiblewar -

If you thought Def Jam: Icon had it bad, spare a thought for the guys behind Invisible War, who were actually following up one of the greatest games of all time. Sadly, while the end result wasn't terrible, it was still sorely disappointing.

Unified ammo, a shorter overall game, and the simplification of the previous title's RPG elements led to accusations that the game had been console-fied for the accompanying Xbox version. Factor in the gigantic level of hype that surrounded Invisible War, and it's easy to see why it didn't live up to Deus Ex. A perfect example of the fact that sequels don't have to be bad to disappoint.

Prince Of Persia: Warrior Within

Prince of Persia: Warrior Within screenshot

2003's Prince of Persia reboot was a thing of beauty. Returning to what made the original game great, it was packed full of exploration, acrobatics, and a fantastic sense of adventure.

So, obviously, the sequel had to go Darker And Edgier. Combat – the secondary element of The Sands of Time – was now far more prevalent, upsetting the balance. The Prince was as aggressive, angry and confused as a 15-year old boy who had just discovered the internet. And he wore guyliner.

Again, this wasn't a terrible game. It just jettisoned most of the things that people loved from The Sands of Time. And no-one messes with The Sands of Time.

New stuff to check out


To add your comment, please login or register

User Comments

BigGorrack18's Avatar


They forgot Castlevania: Harmony of Despair
Posted 00:48 on 11 May 2013
rbevanx's Avatar

rbevanx@ Joey_Bananas

I totally agree with all that, all but Infamous as I still haven't got round to finishing it.
Posted 17:21 on 18 March 2013
Joey_Bananas's Avatar


From this generation, I'd have to say Mass Effect 3 and Killzone 3. Those are just off the top of my head.

Even with Dead Space 3 being mentioned, I'd have to put Dead Space 2 in there as well because I just didn't enjoy the direction it went after the first game. Another one has to have been Resident Evil 5 too. I hadn't played RE4, but I can only imagine from the backlash it received that it didn't stand up to RE4 at all. I did enjoy RE5 though, for my sins.

Actually I just thought of some more. Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception wasn't as good as Uncharted 2: Among Theives, in my opinion. inFamous 2 also wasn't as good as the original inFamous.

Those games weren't flops, they just weren't able to surpass the previous games. I'm surprised there's quite a few PS3 exclusives I thought of as well. If I had to pick a 360 one to be fair, I'd choose Gears of War 2. I didn't think much of that. Gears of War 3 improved on it, but Gears of War is the best of the bunch.
Posted 13:16 on 18 March 2013
Rambolike's Avatar


Correction: Dead Space 3 let down the writer of this article. He lives in his own world, filled with unrealized potential, which he then projects on everyone else.
Posted 19:04 on 17 March 2013
rbevanx's Avatar

rbevanx@ GingerMessiah

and I will put a wager on that it won't :D
Posted 10:42 on 17 March 2013
GingerMessiah's Avatar


I'd like to place a wager that the next Splinter Cell (Blacklist) shall end up in an article like this. :/
Posted 21:51 on 16 March 2013
p0rtalthinker's Avatar

p0rtalthinker@ kark

AC Brotherhood wasn't that big of a disappointment for me personally. Revelations was very boring though. Still hold to the opinion that AC2 has been the best in the series.
Posted 00:08 on 08 February 2013
deaneager's Avatar


Crackdown 2 was a major disappointment to me. Quake 2 was a bit cack too.
Posted 14:26 on 07 February 2013
kark's Avatar

kark@ jeffyboy40

Bioshock 2 was great Manhunt 2 was good on Wii
Posted 14:41 on 06 February 2013
kark's Avatar


Probably add AC Brotherhood and Duke Nukem Forever in there too
Posted 14:40 on 06 February 2013
rbevanx's Avatar


Super Mario Bros 2 was awesome!

Condemned 2 and Virtua Striker 2 would be my choices
Posted 12:05 on 06 February 2013
BC_Animus's Avatar


Gran Turismo 5 should be on that list methinks...
Posted 08:30 on 06 February 2013
jeffyboy40's Avatar


DEF JAM ICON was total and absolute rubbish,but what about Crackdown 2 and Bioshock 2? Manhunt 2 was dissapointing mainly because it was cut to ribbons by th BBFC
Posted 16:53 on 05 February 2013
FantasyMeister's Avatar


Throw Dragon Age 2 in there. You could do the anti-thread, sequels that made franchises better over time - Skyrim, Just Cause 2, Far Cry 3 etc.
Posted 14:33 on 05 February 2013

Related Games

Prince of Persia: Warrior Within

Prince of Persia: Warrior Within
Available For: PS2, PC, Xbox, Cube Genre: Platformer

VideoGamer.com Score7

Deus Ex: Invisible War

Deus Ex: Invisible War
Available For: PC, Xbox Genre: First Person Shooter

Manhunt 2

Manhunt 2
Available For: PS2, Wii, PSP, PC Genre: Stealth

Red Faction Armageddon

Red Faction Armageddon
Available For: Xbox 360, PS3, PC Genre: Action

VideoGamer.com Score6

Resident Evil 6

Resident Evil 6
Available For: Xbox 360, PS3, PC, PS4, Xbox One Genre: Third-person shooter

VideoGamer.com Score6

View Full Site